• Home
  • About
  • Doom II
  • Flog 2010
  • Inspiration

The Nail Was in the Coffin Long Ago

Posted in Music. on Monday, September 15th, 2008 by Derek
Sep 15
Metallica - Death Magnetic
Insert more funeral jokes.

Welcome to another edition of me telling you what is already known. So St. Anger was an utter embarrassment of tin drums and dull songwriting. After watching the album’s documentary Some Kind of Monster, I could only conclude that Lars Ulrich is one of the smuggest motherfuckers on the planet. Yes, you’re the first band ever to express anger in a positive way. Fucking innovators.

After that critical wreckage, the band assembled themselves by just regressing to their past successes. Use the same riffs as found on …And Justice For All? Extend songs minutes past their expiration point? Reintroduce solos that are technically laughable when compared to their already barely-above-average guitar output from the eighties? Check on all of the above.

Most major publications are giving it positive reviews because it’s comfortable, familiar, and infinitely better than St. Anger. But it’s pointless. If you want Metallica, throw in Master of Puppets and then stop it halfway through because all that riffing gets boring pretty damn quickly when taken into the context of today’s music. From the directions acts like Agalloch, Opeth, Cult of Luna, and Mastodon have taken metal, Metallica’s one-dimensional approach is completely irrelevant when overtaken by the musicianship and songwriting exemplified by the former. Attempts at diversity like S&M or “The Unforgiven III” are cringe-worthy.

So why bother? As Henry Rollins said, if a place has electricity, Metallica can play a sold out show. Cash! Cash! Lots of cash! Even with bad public relations stunts throw around, they can still tour the world and watch the bones roll in. As an artistic statement, this album really has no purpose. Why did I just spend four paragraphs on this? Consumerscape blogosphere!

  • Now Playing: Black Sabbath - Mob Rules - 07 - Slipping Away

4 Comments

  1. Jon on September 16th, 2008

    I saw metallica live in August. I do not own any albums and are only vaguely familiar with some of their songs. I was disappointed and left early to catch the end of the Cribs’ set.

  2. Afterglow on September 17th, 2008

    Oh and it gets better. Why not contribute to the loudness wars? http://blog.wired.com/music/2008/09/does-metallicas.html

  3. Skwid on October 2nd, 2008

    In another news… I am baaaaack.

  4. Afterglow on October 3rd, 2008

    I didn’t know you were gone. Welcome to the fray.



Leave a Reply

CAPTCHA Image
CAPTCHA Audio
Refresh Image

Derek MacDonald

  • Photo Stream
  • Categories
    • Computing
    • Film & TV
    • Gaming
    • General
    • Music
    • Sports
    • Visual Art
  • Search






  • Home
  • About
  • Doom II
  • Flog 2010
  • Inspiration

© Copyright Derek MacDonald. All rights reserved.
Designed by FTL Wordpress Themes brought to you by Smashing Magazine

Back to Top